| Year | Theme | |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 1988 | David Haller Andrew Frank and Jason King |
| 2 | 1989 | David Haller |
| 3 | 1990 | Wendy Troope |
| 4 | 1991 | Kim Kehoe Jamie Carracciolo |
| 5 | 1992 | Libby Watch |
| 6 | 1993 | Julie Moye |
| 7 | 1994 | Oh... The Places You'll Go Kelly Kremer |
| 8 | 1995 | Lindsay Carracciolo |
| 9 | 1996 | Julia Elsas |
| 10 | 1997 | I Think I Can Cari Lucks |
| 11 | 1998 | Shiny, Happy People Jen Webster |
| 12 | 1999 | Miracles Aren't Just Magic Ryan Roman |
| 13 | 2000 | Blast Off Into The Future Dena Schlamowitz |
| 14 | 2001 | The Giving Tree Anna Avery |
| 15 | 2002 | The Power is Yours Mary Lynn Stein Kim Freedman |
| 16 | 2003 | Follow the Yellow Brick Road Rebecca Weil - SAR Lisa Berney - STR |
| 17 | 2004 | A Person's A Person, No Matter How Small Jill Goldstein - STR Jody Gansel - SAR |
| 18 | 2005 | The Greatest Camp on Earth Erica Weil - SAR Jessi Fain - STR |
| 19 | 2006 | Willy Wonka and the Choclate Factory Josh Lieberman - SAR Leah Zfaz - STR |
| 20 | 2007 | Where Fairy Tales Do Come True Kaley Tuck - SAR Jordan Shockett - STR |
| 21 | 2008 | Magic Schoolbus Michelle Cravez - STR Steven Moss - SAR |
| 22 | 2009 | Candyland Sydnie Henkin - STR Shelby Krantz - SAR |
| 23 | 2010 | Peanuts Ben Stein - STR Ethan Guthman - SAR |
| 24 | 2011 | Toy Story Lizzie Shapiro - STR Amy Nicotra - SAR |
| 25 | 2012 | The Lion King Kara Hoffman - SAR Felicia Steinberg - STR |
| 26 | 2013 | Do You Believe in Magic? Natalie Barman - STR Debbie Rabinovich - SAR |
| 27 | 2014 | Finding Nemo Hayley Giambalvo - SAR Adam Shapiro - STR |
| 28 | 2015 | Be Your Own Superhero! Noah Baker - STR Zoe Light - SAR |
| 29 | 2016 | Reach for the STARS Micah Feinstein - SAR Shelby Shoup - STR |